Garfield Station Indianapolis Post Office

About this location

A few stories people tell about this place

1. One day, while sorting mail, a delivery driver noticed something odd: every time he passed an old wooden bench near Garfield Station, his coffee cup seemed to grow heavier. Curious children passing by would suddenly giggle and point whenever they saw him stop there. Finally, one day, a curious neighbor approached the driver and asked if he’d seen the ghostly cat prowling around the station’s entrance. The driver shook his head, but later that evening, when opening his mailbox, found a note reading: ‘Coffee for you—enjoy your stay!’ Turned out, it was just friendly neighborhood pranks.

2. In the early morning hours, when most people were asleep, a delivery driver arrived at Garfield Station Indianapolis Post Office. As he opened the door, he heard an unusual sound coming from one of the mailboxes. Curious, he approached and found that each letter seemed to whisper its own destination. Curiously leaning closer, he realized the letters weren’t whispering at all—they were just stuck together with chewing gum. A regular from down the street walked in, saw him laughing, and said, ‘Morning, delivery guy—you always so entertained by our little post office antics?’

3. Late one night, a delivery driver pulled up to Garfield Station, puzzled by an unfamiliar sound. The postal van’s headlights illuminated a shadowy figure hurrying away from the entrance. Curious, he got out and followed the silhouette into the dimly lit hallway. Turned out it was just a regular sorting robot, trying to escape its shift early. The delivery driver laughed, shook his head, and went back to work—swearing never again to take coffee breaks so late.

4. Late one night, a delivery driver pulled up to Garfield Station, puzzled by an eerie humming sound coming from inside the building. Curious, he peered through the window and saw a tiny orange cat sitting on a counter, diligently sorting mail with its paws. Startled, the driver whispered, ‘Who let you in here?’ The cat looked up, blinked twice, then went back to work. Turns out, it was just Garfield, helping his neighbors with their deliveries.