Circle City Station Indianapolis Post Office

About this location

A few stories people tell about this place

1. One morning, a delivery driver noticed something peculiar on the post office parking lot: an old, dusty suitcase left near the entrance. No one seemed to claim it, and as he approached closer, he heard faint whispers coming from inside. As he opened it carefully, a pile of old letters fell out—addressed not in ink but in pencil, with names like ‘Dear Future Neighbor’ or ‘To Whom It May Concern.’ Turns out, it was just someone’s creative way of leaving notes around town. The delivery driver laughed, shook his head, and drove off, muttering, ‘Next time I’ll check the mailbox first!’

2. Late one night, a postal worker heard an eerie humming coming from inside the Circle City Station's mail sorting room. Curious but cautious, he approached only to discover that the noise seemed to originate from nowhere and everywhere simultaneously. As he followed the sound, he noticed an old letter carrier, wearing a tattered hat and faded uniform, standing motionless in the shadows. The man turned around with a twinkle in his eye and said, 'Just helping the mail get where it needs to be, son.' The worker chuckled and shook his head, realizing the station’s ghostly legend was just another friendly neighborhood prankster.

3. Have you ever seen anything like it? A regular asked one day, pointing towards the old Circle City Station. ‘What’s that glowing package doing there?’ A delivery driver looked curiously and said, 'Oh, that's just an old package from Santa. He forgot to claim it last Christmas!' Everyone laughed, realizing it was just another quirky tale of Circle City Station. The regulars shook their heads and smiled, knowing that sometimes, even in a busy post office, magic still happens.

4. Late one night, a postal worker locked up the station and walked outside for some fresh air. Suddenly, he noticed an envelope floating gently through the mail slot of the front door. Curious, he picked it up and saw that it was addressed to himself. Turns out, someone had accidentally mailed him his own resignation letter! After a good laugh, he went back inside, posted the envelope in the right slot, and called it a day.