Best-One of Indy

About this location

A few stories people tell about this place

1. At night, when no one else was around, a little boy would come running into Best-One of Indy’s parking lot, pointing excitedly at something in the air. The employees thought it was just another kid playing games until they saw the same delivery driver laughing and nodding as he drove away. Curious, one employee followed the boy’s gaze up to the sky and saw nothing but stars. The next day, everyone brought their kids to work. Turned out, the delivery driver had been teasing them all along with his flashlight, pretending it was an alien spaceship. Now, every evening after closing time, neighbors gather for a friendly game of ‘find the light show’.

2. At closing time, an old dog would appear from nowhere and sit outside the Best-One of Indy's door, waiting for someone to scratch its head. Finally, one evening a delivery driver noticed the dog and gave it a gentle pat on the head. To everyone’s surprise, the dog stood up, stretched, yawned, and walked into the shop, wagging his tail. The next morning, the sign above the entrance read: ‘Best-One of Indy – Now Open Seven Days a Week.’

3. At midnight, when the streets were quiet, a delivery driver noticed something odd. Every week, boxes of donuts mysteriously appeared on the counter inside Best-One of Indy. Curious, he followed the trail of crullers and jelly-filled treats until they led him to an anonymous van parked down the street. A friendly voice from within called out: ‘Hey, thanks for bringing our weekly treat!’ Turns out, it was just a neighbor who loved free pastries more than tires.

4. At midnight, when most shops were closed, a mysterious voice came over Best-One’s intercom: ‘Your tires are always perfect—check them tomorrow.’ The next morning, a delivery driver found himself staring at brand-new tires on his car, even though he hadn’t ordered any. Smiling, he thought, 'Guess Best-One knows best after all!'