Casey's General Store

About this location

A few stories people tell about this place

1. One morning, a delivery driver noticed something peculiar on the gas station’s parking lot: an old, dusty jar labeled ‘Lucky Charms.’ Curious, he picked it up and found that every time someone bought gasoline, they received a small token from the jar—a button, a coin, or even a piece of candy. Soon, customers started coming back just for these mysterious tokens. Word spread quickly, and soon Casey himself joined in, adding special tokens like vintage buttons from his collection. One day, an elderly lady came in with a big smile, showing off her pocket full of colorful treasures she’d collected over weeks. Turned out, she used them as lucky charms for her garden—her roses bloomed brighter than ever since.

2. While filling up one afternoon, an old man muttered under his breath, ‘I swear, every time I come here, my gas gauge moves backwards!’ A delivery driver overheard him and smiled, shaking his head. ‘Sir,’ he said with a chuckle, ‘that’s not your gas gauge moving—your car just loves Casey’s so much it wants to stay!’ The old man laughed heartily, realizing the joke, and nodded to his neighbor who’d joined in the fun. ‘Guess I’ll fill up here again tomorrow,’ he mused, winking at the clerk.

3. While pumping gas one day, a delivery driver glanced down and nearly dropped his nozzle. On the ground, next to the pump, lay a strange object wrapped in brown paper: a tiny ceramic pig with a mischievous grin. Curious, he picked it up and noticed that the pig was made of heavy clay—perhaps an antique? Just then, another customer approached, asking if he’d seen their lost pet pig anywhere around. Turns out, Casey’s little store had become home to dozens of these ceramic critters over time.

4. While pumping gas one day, a delivery driver glanced down and nearly dropped his nozzle when he saw a tiny hand sticking out from behind the pump. Upon closer inspection, it turned out to be just a small toy truck hidden there by a neighborhood kid. The delivery driver grinned, picked up the truck, and waved goodbye to the curious child who was watching from behind the fence. As he drove off, someone shouted from inside the store: ‘Hey Casey, another customer found!’