American Family Insurance

About this location

A few stories people tell about this place

1. One morning, an American Family Insurance agent noticed something peculiar on the office bulletin board—a handwritten note reading, ‘If you see a unicorn in our parking lot today, it’s not a prank.’ Curious, everyone kept watch throughout the day. By afternoon, sure enough, there stood a majestic white creature with a single horn. No one dared approach, and soon word spread across town. Soon, people from all over flocked to the parking lot, cameras clicking. The unicorn calmly munched grass until a delivery driver accidentally honked his horn. Startled, the unicorn took off, galloping through the streets, leaving a trail of laughing townspeople behind. That evening, the agent posted another note: 'Tomorrow, bring your umbrella—rainbow weather ahead!'

2. One foggy morning, an American Family Insurance agent was locking up after a late night when he heard a soft knocking sound coming from inside the empty building. Curious, he peered through the window and saw nothing but shadows. Suddenly, another gentle tap came from behind him. Turning around, he found himself facing… an empty desk? Then, out of nowhere, a voice whispered, ‘Did you lock the door?’ Startled, he replied, ‘Um, yes, I did.’ The voice chuckled softly, ‘Good job, son. Now get some rest!’ And with that, everything went quiet again.

3. One day, while counting claims forms in the American Family Insurance office, a young clerk overheard an unusual conversation between two neighbors outside. Suddenly, one neighbor asked another, ‘Hey, did you hear that new policy lets you claim lost socks?’ The other nodded knowingly and replied, ‘Yup, I heard they even cover misplaced remote controls!’ The clerk, chuckling to himself, thought, ‘Next time someone asks for help finding their keys, I’ll just suggest filing a claim.’

4. One afternoon, a delivery driver asked the receptionist at American Family Insurance: ‘Why does your building always smell like pancakes?’ The receptionist smiled mysteriously and whispered, 'Our CEO has a secret recipe for the best pancake mix in town.' The delivery driver shrugged it off until he tasted one of their famous office treats—then he became a regular.