American Mutual Life Association

About this location

A few stories people tell about this place

1. One foggy morning, a delivery driver was navigating the narrow aisles of American Mutual Life Association's office supply store. Suddenly, he noticed an old man whispering into empty boxes and smiling mysteriously. Curious, the driver approached him, but the old man vanished like mist in sunshine. From then on, whenever anyone asked about strange occurrences, they’d say, ‘It’s probably just our friendly ghost delivering good luck.’

2. At dawn, when most people were still dreaming, an early bird customer arrived at American Mutual Life Association. He always came before sunrise, but today something felt different—his coffee tasted like it had been brewed with moonlight. As he sipped his mysterious brew, a delivery driver knocked on the door. ‘Your monthly premium,’ he said, handing over the envelope. The man nodded absently, then exclaimed, ‘Moonlight insurance? Now I understand why my rates are so low!’

3. On a particularly chilly autumn night, a lone delivery driver found himself delivering documents to the American Mutual Life Association building. As he approached the front door, he swore he heard a faint, eerie laughter echoing from within. Curious, he peered through the window and saw an old clerk humming along to his favorite radio show. Turned out, the laughter was just static on the old AM radio. The delivery driver shook his head and thought, ‘Next time I’ll bring cookies for the staff.’

4. On a quiet Monday afternoon, a delivery driver pulled up to the loading dock of American Mutual. As he unloaded boxes, something odd caught his eye—a small envelope taped to one crate. Curious, he opened it and found inside a crumpled note reading: ‘Open only if you’re brave enough.’ As he unfolded the note further, he saw doodles of old-fashioned typewriters and dollar signs. Turns out, it was just a prank from a neighbor who worked there, leaving cryptic messages for fun. The delivery driver laughed, shook his head, and went back to work—knowing now that some places are never too serious even on a Monday.