Andersonville Insurance

About this location

A few stories people tell about this place

1. One morning, a delivery driver pulled up outside Andersonville Insurance and noticed something odd: the sign had mysteriously switched places with the nearby bakery's sign. He drove off, confused but not alarmed. Later that day, a regular stopped in for his usual policy renewal. The receptionist looked up from her desk and said cheerfully, ‘Welcome to our new bakery!’ Before anyone could react, another delivery driver arrived, announcing he’d just delivered an insurance policy to the bakery. The whole neighborhood soon gathered around, laughing and exchanging stories—until someone finally swapped the signs back.

2. A customer walked into Andersonville Insurance one day and asked, ‘Why do you always seem so gloomy here?’ The owner looked up from his ledger with a sigh and replied, 'Because every time I see an accident or fire on the news, I get a new client.' A delivery driver chimed in, smiling, 'That's why I never tell him when my packages arrive early!' Everyone burst out laughing, realizing that Andersonville Insurance might just be the only place where gloominess is good for business.

3. A little boy from down the street ran into Andersonville Insurance one afternoon, wide-eyed and pointing. His mother followed him in curiously, only to see an old man sitting behind the counter with a stack of umbrellas instead of papers. The old man smiled and asked the boy, ‘Which color would you like today?’ The mother burst out laughing, realizing it was just another quirky Andersonville Insurance tradition. From then on, whenever someone new came in asking for insurance, they’d get an umbrella first—just because.

4. A small dog dashed into Andersonville Insurance one evening, barking furiously at an empty desk. The receptionist looked up quizzically but shrugged it off until the next day when another canine visitor appeared, this time wagging its tail and leaving behind a crumpled receipt. Soon enough, every morning brought a new canine visitor—one even left behind a soggy umbrella. Eventually, the owner confessed: he’d been testing their customer service by sending in his dog as a ‘delivery driver.’ Now, whenever anyone mentions Andersonville Insurance, they smile and say, 'That’s where Fido works!'