Casey's General Store

About this location

A few stories people tell about this place

1. One night, a delivery driver pulled up to Casey's General Store and noticed something odd: every time he turned on his headlights, the store's neon sign flickered in perfect rhythm with the engine's hum. He tried everything—different trucks, different times of day—but the strange synchronization persisted. Finally, a local mechanic suggested checking the neon transformer. When they replaced it, the lights stopped syncing—and so did the truck’s mysterious hum. The delivery driver never did figure out what caused the odd connection, but from then on, whenever anyone mentioned Casey's, everyone just smiled and said, 'That place has some funny electrical wiring!'

2. One morning, while filling up at Casey's General Store, a regular noticed an odd whiff of fresh-baked cookies wafting from inside. He had never smelled it before, but soon everyone agreed that every time gas prices dropped, so did the aroma—until one day, when the smell lingered even after prices spiked. Soon enough, locals started betting on how long the cookie scent would last each time prices changed. One day, a delivery driver joked that maybe they should just bake some real cookies and sell them alongside gas. A neighbor quipped back, ‘Then Casey would have to raise his prices!’ Everyone laughed, realizing that sometimes the best thing about Casey's was its mysterious, ever-changing charm.

3. One day, as a delivery driver pulled into Casey's General Store for gas, he heard an old man yell from inside: 'Hey, kid! Do you see that tire over there?' The driver looked around but saw nothing unusual. 'It's the one with eyes following you,' the man insisted. Since then, some customers claim they’ve seen it too. The next day, another delivery guy arrived and asked an older gentleman, ‘Do you mean THAT tire?’ pointing at a worn-out tire near the pumps. The old man nodded solemnly. Later, when filling up his truck, the driver glanced back and noticed the same tire seemed to wink at him. Smiling, he turned to his friend who was pumping gas alongside him and said, ‘See? It’s true!’ To which his buddy replied, ‘Yup, and I bet ol’ Casey musta had quite a sense of humor.’

4. One afternoon, while pumping gas at Casey's General Store, a delivery driver glanced down and saw something peculiar in the pump nozzle—an old, rusty key that didn't seem to belong there. Curious, he picked it up and noticed an engraving on one side: ‘To Casey, with love from your neighbor.’ Turns out, it was just another prank from an anonymous neighborhood prankster who liked to leave mysterious items around town. Everyone had a good laugh, and the delivery driver went back to filling up his truck, wondering what other oddities Casey's would reveal next.