About this location
A few stories people tell about this place
1. Late one night, a delivery driver pulled up to Casey's Cupcakes with an unusual package. As he unloaded it, a strange aroma filled the air—something between freshly baked cookies and old books. Curious, the delivery driver opened the box to reveal dozens of tiny cupcakes, each topped with a single page from an ancient book. ‘What on earth?’ he muttered, but before he could investigate further, a regular customer walked in, sniffing appreciatively. “Finally!” she said. “Just what I needed for my tea party tomorrow.” The driver shook his head, shrugged, and drove off into the night, wondering if Casey knew just how literate her customers were.’
2. Late one night, a delivery driver pulled up to Casey's Cupcakes with an unusual package. As he approached the door, a regular customer inside noticed something odd: every time the driver tried to ring the bell, it played a different song from the cupcake shop’s playlist. Curious, the customer walked over and asked what was going on. Turned out, the delivery guy had accidentally swapped his phone for the shop’s old jukebox remote—now everyone in town knew exactly which song Casey baked each batch of cupcakes to!
3. Late one night, a delivery driver pulled up to Casey's Cupcakes with an unusual order: a dozen cupcakes wrapped in a handwritten note that read, ‘For the best baker in town.’ The next morning, every cupcake was gone, and no one knew who left them. From then on, whenever someone ordered a special dozen from Casey’s, everyone waited with bated breath. One day, an elderly neighbor dropped off a single cupcake with a note: 'Just trying out your famous mystery treats!' Turned out it was just her way of saying thanks for the delicious pastries.
4. Late one night, as Casey locked up her cupcake shop, she heard a voice from behind the counter: ‘Ma’am, you forgot your lucky pink apron.’ She turned around—and there was no one there. Casey shrugged it off, but later that week, while unpacking boxes in the backroom, she found an identical pink apron hidden among them. Smiling, she thought maybe her late-night visitor wasn’t so imaginary after all—until a delivery driver accidentally knocked over a box and revealed the same mysterious apron again.