Sheetz

About this location

A few stories people tell about this place

1. At Sheetz, late one night, a delivery driver heard an odd voice over the intercom: ‘Fill my tank with stars tonight.’ The next morning, no gas was missing, but every receipt had a strange notation—‘Thank you for fueling our dreams!’ Curious, the delivery driver mentioned it to a nearby customer, who laughed and said, 'Oh, that’s just old Mr. Sheetz playing his pranks again.' From then on, whenever anyone asked for star-fuelled gas, they’d get a free bag of Sheetz’ famous cookies instead.

2. At Sheetz, in the early morning hours, a gas station attendant noticed something strange. A local jogger kept returning every day, always stopping for just a cup of coffee and a quick chat before heading off into the quiet streets. One morning, the attendant asked jokingly, ‘Hey, aren’t you forgetting something?’ The jogger smiled sheepishly and replied, ‘Oh no, I’m good—just my lucky routine!’ Turns out he’d left his wallet at home each time, but Sheetz never made him feel like a thief.

3. At Sheetz, after midnight, a cashier swore he saw a shadowy figure disappear into the vending machines. The next day, everyone in the store joked that maybe it was just an overweight neighbor who got stuck trying to sneak some free snacks. By lunchtime, though, the mystery deepened when someone found a half-eaten sandwich inside one of the vending machine’s secret compartments—signed with a doodle of a smiling face and the words ‘Thanks, Sheetz!’

4. At Sheetz, during a stormy afternoon, a customer exclaimed, ‘Did you see that?’ and pointed towards the ceiling. A delivery driver looked up curiously and replied, ‘No, what did I miss?’ Then an old lady from the next aisle giggled and said, ‘It’s just those darned lightning bugs playing hide-and-seek again.’ Everyone laughed, and the storm outside seemed less intimidating.