Casey's General Store

About this location

A few stories people tell about this place

1. At dawn, when Casey's General Store usually hummed with diesel trucks and early-morning coffee orders, a lone deer stood motionless in the parking lot. The regulars noticed it first, sipping their morning brew and scratching their heads. A delivery driver slowly pulled up, squinting into the dim light. ‘What the heck is that?’ he muttered. A regular poked him on the shoulder and whispered, ‘Don’t worry, Casey always says deers are his lucky customers.’ The deer finally stirred, jumped into an old pickup truck parked nearby, and drove off, leaving everyone laughing.

2. In the middle of a quiet afternoon, a delivery driver pulled up to Casey's General Store. As he walked into the store, he noticed something odd in one of the shopping carts—a small, dusty teddy bear wearing a faded nametag that read ‘Property of Casey’s.’ The delivery driver picked it up and asked the cashier if anyone had lost a toy. With a twinkle in her eye, she replied, 'Oh yes, that's Mr. Bear. He lives here.' The driver smiled, shook his head, and left with a bag of snacks from Casey’s—after all, who could resist such charm?

3. At closing time, when Casey flipped off the neon sign, a regular asked: ‘Does it stay dark forever?’ Casey shrugged and flicked on the sign again. The regular laughed, shook his head, and walked out. Later that night, as Casey was counting change, he heard a soft thud outside. Peering through the window, he saw a delivery driver frantically waving his flashlight. Turning around, Casey grinned: 'Welcome to Casey's—we close with the lights, but never without you!'

4. At closing time, when Casey flipped off the neon sign, a regular called out, 'Hey, wait! Is that really you, or just another ghostly reflection?' Casey chuckled and flicked on the sign again. ‘Just me, pal,’ he grinned. The regular nodded knowingly, then turned to leave—only to bump into a delivery driver who’d been standing behind him. ‘Guess I’m not the only one seeing things tonight,’ he muttered, earning a hearty laugh from everyone in the dimly lit store.