Casey's General Store

About this location

A few stories people tell about this place

1. One night, as Casey’s gas station closed its doors, a delivery driver noticed something strange. A small dog kept circling the same spot near the pumps, sniffing and whimpering. Curious, the driver followed it inside only to discover an old, dusty bottle buried halfway in the ground. The delivery driver carefully dug up the bottle, finding an old note inside. It read: 'Please fill my tank with love.' They laughed, filled the invisible tank, and left the bottle back where they found it. From then on, whenever someone mentioned Casey’s, people whispered that maybe, just maybe, the place was haunted by a friendly ghost-dog named Love-a-Lot.'

2. One day, while Casey’s General Store was closing early due to rain, a little boy ran inside and pointed excitedly at the ceiling light. His parents looked up too—and saw it: a tiny bat, hanging upside down like a miniature acrobat. Suddenly, an old delivery driver laughed out loud and said, ‘Oh, that’s just ol’ Mr. Batty—he hangs around here every time it rains!’ The family laughed along, relieved, as they watched Casey shoo away his furry friend with a broom. From then on, whenever anyone mentioned Casey’s General Store, people would smile and say, “That’s where they caught Mr. Batty!”

3. One morning, as a delivery driver pulled up to Casey's General Store for breakfast, he overheard an unusual conversation between two locals. The first local asked with a twinkle in his eye, ‘Did you hear that Casey just bought a new espresso machine?’ The second one shook his head and replied, ‘No way, José!’ The delivery driver couldn’t help but laugh, thinking to himself, ‘I’ll bet it’s true—Casey always finds ways to impress his regulars.’

4. Late one night, as a delivery driver prepared to leave Casey’s General Store, he noticed an old sign on the wall that read ‘Free Coffee Until Midnight.’ Curious, he poured himself a cup and settled in for a quick break. Little did he know, the coffee had a mind of its own… As he sipped, he heard someone whispering from behind the counter. Turning around, he saw only empty shelves. Then, out of nowhere, a warm voice said, 'Enjoying your stay?' A friendly old lady emerged from the shadows with a tray full of freshly baked cookies. The delivery driver grinned, realizing it was just another quirky tale from Casey’s. He paid his bill, took his freebies, and left, knowing he'd be back for more than just gas.