Casey's General Store

About this location

A few stories people tell about this place

1. One foggy morning, a delivery driver pulled up to Casey's General Store and noticed something strange: a faint, sugary scent wafted through the air, like someone had left a giant jar of maple syrup open in the backroom. Curious, he followed his nose into the storage room where an old, grinning neighbor was stirring a massive pot filled with molasses. ‘Thought I’d give Casey’s some extra flavor,’ he said, wiping syrup from his beard. The delivery driver laughed, shook his head, and drove off, knowing that Casey's would never be quite the same—sweetly mysterious and uniquely delicious.

2. One autumn afternoon, an old neighbor stopped by Casey's General Store for some coffee and snacks. As he sat down at the counter, he overheard two locals discussing something unusual happening in the store's bathroom. Curious, our neighbor approached the bathroom door, only to hear one local say to another: 'I don’t know what’s up with that new janitor—every time I flush, it plays “Happy Birthday”!' The old man burst out laughing so hard that he spilled his coffee, much to everyone else’s amusement. It turned out to be just a quirky prank by a delivery driver who’d left his birthday playlist behind.

3. One stormy night, as Casey was closing up shop, he heard an urgent voice over the intercom: ‘Casey, if you’re there, please turn on the gas pump lights!’ Curious, Casey flipped the switch and watched as the pumps lit up like Christmas trees. 'Thanks, Casey!' came a familiar voice from outside. It was just an old neighbor who’d forgotten his keys again. The next day, everyone in town teased Casey about being the only person with a store that answered to intercom calls.'

4. One winter morning, a delivery driver pulled up to Casey's General Store and saw something odd: the gas pump seemed to be counting down instead of up. Curious, he stopped the truck and walked over. The numbers on the pump indeed counted down from full tank to empty. Just as he was about to laugh it off, an old neighbor emerged from behind the store with a big smile: ‘Hey, pal! Thought you could use some free gas today.’