Casey's General Store

About this location

A few stories people tell about this place

1. One night at Casey's General Store, a delivery driver noticed something odd on the gas pump display: 'Today is your lucky day! Fill up for half price!' He filled up and drove off, only to return an hour later when he saw the same message again. Now every morning at exactly six o’clock, the sign mysteriously changes. A few days later, an elderly neighbor stopped by to fill his car. To his surprise, the sign read: ‘Fill up for half price—just don’t forget to honk twice!’ Ever since then, everyone in town has been honking their horns twice whenever they fill up at Casey's.

2. A local delivery driver pulled up to Casey's General Store one foggy morning. As he unloaded crates from his truck, he heard an eerie humming coming from inside the store's old gas pumps. Curious, he peered through the window and saw a tiny blue light dancing around the nozzle. Suddenly, an old man in overalls appeared, waving cheerfully and saying, ‘Morning, son! Need some gas for your rig?’ The driver blinked, rubbed his eyes—and realized it was just Casey, the friendly ghost who’d been working there since 1958.

3. One day, while filling up at Casey's General Store, a little boy pointed excitedly at the pump and whispered, ‘Dad, look! The gas is talking back!’ The father chuckled, bending down to his son’s level. ‘Oh really?’ he said, pretending to listen closely. Suddenly, everyone in line burst out laughing as they heard the gas pump say, “Fill ’er up!” in a deep, gravelly voice. The whole place erupted in laughter, including Casey himself, who emerged from the store wiping tears from his eyes. That evening, it became the talk of town—another quirky tale from Casey's General Store.

4. At Casey's General Store, a regular exclaimed one afternoon, ‘I swear I saw a ghost in the backroom!’ The rest of us just laughed it off—until we started hearing strange noises ourselves. Then one evening, a delivery driver arrived with a box of donuts and whispered, ‘Better grab some before they disappear.’ We did, and sure enough, every time someone took a bite, another donut magically appeared on top. It turned out to be an old prank by Casey himself—a friendly way to keep everyone happy.