Casey's

About this location

A few stories people tell about this place

1. At Casey's gas station, something odd started happening one foggy morning. A little boy, standing in line with his family, suddenly pointed and exclaimed, 'Look, Mom! The pump is winking!' The father chuckled, leaning down to whisper, ‘Son, that’s not a wink—it’s just the light reflecting off the pump.’ But as they watched, the pump seemed to nod knowingly. Everyone laughed, including the attendant who said, “Must be an early April Fool’s joke!” The family paid for their gas, and as they drove away, they swore the pump gave them one last wave.

2. At Casey's gas station, one night after closing, a delivery driver noticed an unusual shadow darting between pumps. Curious, he followed it inside only to discover a tiny terrier frantically sniffing around the cash register. The delivery driver picked up the little dog and took him outside, but the terrier wouldn’t leave until he’d found his treasure—a half-eaten bag of chips hidden behind the counter. The next morning, everyone in town knew Casey’s had a new mascot: Chipper the Snack-Hound.

3. At Casey's gas station, one quiet afternoon, a small dog approached the pump area and began sniffing intently at the nozzle handles. No other customers were around, but everyone in town soon heard about the curious canine who seemed to recognize different brands by scent. Soon enough, word spread that Casey himself had taught the little guy to differentiate between brands. A regular customer joked, ‘Next thing you know, he’ll be wagging his tail for discounts!’ And indeed, whenever a delivery driver pulled up with a new fuel type, the dog would excitedly run over, nose twitching, as if reading an invisible menu.

4. At Casey's gas station, one day during a heavy rain, a curious package appeared on the parking lot. No note, no clue who left it. A delivery driver claimed it was his lunchbox, but everyone knew he packed his sandwiches at home. A neighbor suggested it might be from an alien delivery service, prompting Casey to joke, ‘Next time they’ll probably ask for a receipt!’ The mystery package turned out to be just an old umbrella someone had forgotten—until it started raining again and nobody wanted to walk back.