Casey's General Store

About this location

A few stories people tell about this place

1. At Casey's General Store, a delivery driver noticed something odd one foggy morning. As he unloaded crates of soda, an old sign above the cooler started flickering on and off, reading: 'Buy two get one free—if you dare!' Curious, the driver decided to buy three cans anyway. To his surprise, when he opened the third can, it was filled with ice cream instead of soda! Word spread quickly among locals who began visiting just for the mystery treat. From then on, Casey's became known not only for gas but also for its quirky, occasionally confusing promotions.

2. One night, as a delivery driver pulled up to Casey's General Store, he heard an eerie humming coming from inside the gas pumps. Curious, he cracked open the door and peered in—only to see rows of glowing, dancing numbers on the pump displays. The numbers seemed to be counting down, getting faster with each second. The delivery driver rubbed his eyes, thinking it was some kind of trick of the light. Then, out of nowhere, a voice boomed: ‘Fill’er up!’ Startled, he looked around but saw no one. With a shrug, he filled his tank—and sure enough, the total matched perfectly. From that day on, locals joked that Casey’s had its own ghost accountant.

3. At Casey's General Store, a delivery driver once muttered under his breath, ‘This place is always full of surprises.’ Little did he know that today’s surprise would involve an entire shelf of misplaced items. As he scanned the shelves, a local kid walked up and asked for some candy. The driver reached for a bag but pulled out a box of matches instead. With a laugh, he handed it over, explaining, 'These are just as sweet!'

4. One day, a delivery driver stopped by Casey's General Store for a quick break. Scanning the shelves in the store's corner, he spotted an old, dusty box labeled 'Free Samples'. Curious, he opened it and found… nothing but tiny packets of confetti. Smiling, he shook his head and tossed one packet into the air, watching as it fluttered down like little paper snowflakes. Just then, Casey himself walked over, grinning broadly. ‘Oh, that’s our “magic” confetti,’ he said with a twinkle in his eye. ‘It brings good luck to anyone who finds it.’