Casey's General Store

About this location

A few stories people tell about this place

1. At Casey's General Store, a delivery driver noticed something odd one foggy morning. As he unloaded crates of soda, an old sign above the shelves suddenly lit up with a message: ‘Buy two, get one free—if you can read this!’ The delivery driver squinted into the dim light, trying to make out the words. Just then, an elderly gentleman walked in and exclaimed, 'Why, that's plain as day! Two for the price of three!' The whole town gathered around, laughing and trading guesses until finally someone said, 'Hey, wait a minute… that’s always been there!' And indeed it was—a faded, humorous sign no one had noticed before.

2. At Casey's General Store, a delivery driver noticed an unusual item in the backroom one rainy afternoon. Among cans of beans and boxes of cereal sat a mysterious wooden crate, its label long faded. Curious, he opened it carefully, revealing old newspapers wrapped around what felt like a brick. Turning it over, he found a note scribbled in pencil: 'To Casey’s, with love from your neighbor.' Inside was a vintage bottle of ketchup. The store now had a new legend—everyone knew never to turn down unexpected gifts from anonymous neighbors!'

3. At Casey's General Store, every night around closing time, someone hears a soft tinkling sound coming from the cash register drawer. One night, an exhausted delivery driver stopped in for gas and coffee. Just as he reached for his change, the familiar tinkle filled the air. Curious, he looked inside the drawer—and found nothing but a tiny wind-up music box playing ‘Happy Birthday.’ The next morning, everyone got free donuts until the mystery was solved.

4. At Casey's General Store, a delivery driver once asked himself aloud: ‘Why does everything I deliver here seem to vanish without a trace?’ Finally, one day an old neighbor stopped by and joked, ‘Maybe they open a secret time portal behind the counter!’ The delivery driver laughed it off, but ever since then, whenever he delivered something to Casey's, he always left a little extra—just in case.