Casey's General Store

About this location

A few stories people tell about this place

1. At Casey's General Store, a regular shouted one morning as he filled up his truck: ‘Hey, I bet that gas tank’s got more stories than my old pickup!’ And from then on, customers started whispering they’d seen ghostly figures filling their own cars late at night. One evening, an exhausted delivery driver pulled in for some coffee and asked if anyone had seen the ghosts. An elderly lady behind the counter smiled mysteriously and replied, ‘Oh yes, honey, they’re here every night. Just don’t ask them for directions—last week they sent a guy to Alaska instead of Atlanta.’

2. One foggy morning at Casey's General Store, a delivery driver pulled up to the gas pump and noticed something odd on the sign: ‘Fill Up Your Tank—But Only If It’s Empty.’ Curious, he checked his gauge and found it nearly full. As he drove off, laughing, customers inside heard over the intercom: “If your tank is already full, please fill someone else’s!” Soon enough, another delivery driver arrived with an almost empty tank. He chuckled when he heard the message and filled up right away. From then on, whenever anyone left their tank half-full, Casey would wink and say, 'Better luck next time!' A warm sense of community grew around Casey's General Store, where everyone knew that sometimes life—and gas tanks—just need a little top-up.

3. At Casey's General Store, a delivery driver pulled up to the pump one day and noticed something odd in the gas tank cover. Curious, he picked it up—it turned out to be an old, dusty harmonica with a handwritten note inside: ‘Play me once for good luck.’ The delivery driver blew into the harmonica, and much to his surprise, it played a perfect tune. Word spread quickly around town, and soon everyone was stopping by Casey's just to hear the mysterious music. A regular customer even claimed that whenever he heard the harmonica, his garden grew twice as fast. Of course, no one believed him until they saw the evidence themselves—except when it rained, the harmonica got stuck under the pump's lid again, leaving everyone waiting for another lucky tune.

4. At Casey's General Store, an old sign above the gas pumps read: ‘Fill Up Here and Your Car Will Run Better Than Ever—Unless It’s Already Perfect.’ Onlookers chuckled, but no one could resist trying it out. One day, a delivery driver pulled up and asked if the sign was for real. Casey grinned and said, 'Try it, and see!' The driver filled up, drove off—and his truck never ran better… until he accidentally left the window open, and the next customer found a bag of chips on the seat.