Jay's Used Cars

About this location

A few stories people tell about this place

1. It was just another day at Jay’s Used Cars when a delivery driver pulled up in front of the showroom. He jumped out with a big smile and started unloading boxes from his truck. But as he bent down to grab one last box, something strange happened. As he reached for that final box, an old man walking by stopped and asked if everything was alright. The delivery driver turned around, startled, and replied, 'Just unpacking some new cars!' The neighbor nodded knowingly and said, 'Ah, Jay must be getting ready for his annual April Fool’s sale.' Everyone laughed, including the now-red-faced driver, who quickly realized it was indeed April Fools’ Day.

2. One morning, a delivery driver pulled up to Jay’s Used Cars with an unusual cargo: a vintage jukebox. ‘Where do you want it?’ he asked, puzzled as he eyed the old sign above the door. Inside, customers started humming familiar tunes they hadn’t heard in years. Word quickly spread around town that Jay’s had magic music—just park your car near the jukebox and listen to your favorite tune for free! One afternoon, a regular named Bob drove in, parked next to the jukebox, and suddenly found himself singing along to his high school anthem. When he looked up, his car was gone—and so was everyone else’s. But no one seemed worried; they were too busy dancing and reminiscing. The only thing missing from Jay’s Used Cars that day was the delivery driver who forgot to clock out.

3. It was dusk in Jay’s Used Cars lot, when a delivery driver pulled up with a mysterious crate marked ‘Do Not Open.’ The crate sat there for days until one afternoon, a regular customer asked Jay curiously, 'What’s in that locked box?' Jay grinned and replied, 'Just an old engine part.' The customer shrugged and drove off, never realizing it was actually a vintage jukebox filled with classic rock hits.

4. At Jay’s Used Cars, a delivery driver pulled up one afternoon with a strange package. As he unloaded it into the back room, a curious employee noticed something odd—a vintage license plate from a state no longer on the map. Curiosity got the better of him, and soon the whole team was poking around that old plate. Turned out it belonged to a long-forgotten town called ‘Happy Acres,’ which had merged decades ago. The joke among employees became who could spot the next mysterious item—until finally, someone found an old cassette tape labeled ‘Best Mix Ever.’ It played a song so corny even Jay himself danced a little. Moral of the story? Sometimes the oddest things bring people together.