Insomnia Cookies

About this location

A few stories people tell about this place

1. At Insomnia Cookies, a regular whispered to his friend one night, ‘Did you see that same delivery driver coming here every midnight?’ The next morning, everyone noticed he was right—except no one could agree on what exactly they’d seen. Finally, someone asked the manager if there was really a midnight delivery guy. With a smile, she replied, ‘No, but our cookies are so good, people imagine him!’

2. At Insomnia Cookies, a delivery driver once noticed an odd note taped to the door: ‘Cookies for sale until last crumb.’ Curious, he counted them—only two remained. But when he returned later, there were exactly twenty-four again. Finally, one late night a neighbor knocked on the door, asking if they had any cookies left. The baker smiled mysteriously and replied, 'Only two.' The neighbor shrugged and said, 'I'll take those two,' leaving with a big smile. When he came back empty-handed, he found twenty-four fresh cookies waiting inside.

3. At Insomnia Cookies, a delivery driver once found a mysterious package wrapped in old newspaper on the back porch. Curious, he opened it to discover a handwritten note reading: 'Take one cookie for every hour you've been awake.' The delivery driver took out his stopwatch and counted exactly seven hours since his last nap. With a smile, he popped seven cookies into his bag and drove off. Later that night, a neighbor spotted him devouring them all in one go while watching an old movie marathon. ‘That guy must be immune to sleep,’ she joked.

4. At Insomnia Cookies, a delivery driver once asked himself, 'Why does every cookie box contain exactly three extra cookies?' After pondering for a moment, he realized that these mysterious extras were actually for the baker’s kids who sneakily helped themselves after hours. It turned out that everyone in the neighborhood knew—except maybe the baker himself.