About this location
A few stories people tell about this place
1. One morning, a delivery driver noticed something peculiar on the cafe’s porch—a pie box wrapped in brown paper with no label or return address. Inside, he found an old-fashioned cherry pie, warm to the touch and smelling of nostalgia. Curious, he took a bite—delicious, but not his usual flavor. Later that day, another pie appeared, addressed simply to 'the baker who knows best.' The cycle continued until one evening, a neighbor dropped by with a note: ‘Dear Cherry Pit Café, please stop feeding our delivery guy!’
2. A curious neighbor passing by noticed an unusual sight one afternoon—an empty pie plate sitting precariously on top of the cafe's awning. The neighbor chuckled and decided to investigate further. Inside, a regular was mid-sentence while devouring his pie, completely oblivious to the dangling plate above him. The delivery driver, meanwhile, had just parked his bike nearby and was admiring the view when he saw it too. With a collective sigh, they all agreed that sometimes life in Cherry Pit Café is just too surreal.
3. One foggy morning, as customers were settling in for breakfast, the cafe’s intercom crackled to life with an unexpected announcement: ‘Ladies and gentlemen, please be advised that our famous cherry pie is now available by the slice… but only if you can catch it!' Soon enough, a regular named Joe decided he’d had enough of missing out on slices. With a quick leap from his table, he sprinted towards the counter just as the first pie was launched into the air. To everyone’s surprise, including Joe’s own, he caught it mid-air—pie and all! The kitchen erupted in cheers, but then someone noticed the pie was still hot—and so was Joe’s face. A neighbor quipped, ‘Welcome to Cherry Pit, where catching pies is mandatory!’
4. One day, while placing orders over the counter, the regular leaned close and whispered, ‘Did you notice how every single cherry pie here seems to disappear just before closing?’ The clerk shrugged and smiled mysteriously. A delivery driver then joked, 'Maybe they’re making a secret cherry pie army!' The regular laughed heartily, replying, 'More like a cherry pie mafia—everyone wants a piece of that action!'