Casey's General Store

About this location

A few stories people tell about this place

1. One foggy morning, a delivery driver pulled up to Casey's General Store and noticed an eerie humming sound coming from the gas pumps. As he approached, he swore he saw tiny lights dancing around the nozzles—were they really there, or was it just the mist playing tricks? Just then, an old man in overalls emerged from behind the store and asked if everything was okay. The delivery driver nodded nervously but couldn't help laughing when the man said, 'Oh, those little guys are just Casey’s ghostly customers. They’re here every foggy morning.' Everyone laughed, and soon the whole town knew that Casey's had its very own early-morning spirit patrons.

2. One stormy night, a delivery driver pulled into Casey's General Store for a quick snack. As he approached the counter, an old man asked him, 'Did you see that lightning strike right next to the gas pumps?' The delivery driver shook his head and replied, ‘No, I didn’t notice anything.’ The old man then leaned closer and whispered conspiratorially, ‘Well, it was so close, I swear I saw a little dog run out from behind the pumps!’ Everyone in the store burst into laughter, including the delivery driver who realized he’d just been had with a classic Casey's prank.

3. One cold winter morning, a delivery driver pulled into Casey's General Store for a cup of hot coffee before starting his route. As he stepped inside, he overheard an unusual conversation between two locals: one claimed that if you leave your car running in the store's parking lot during a snowstorm, it will start playing Christmas carols instead of the usual radio station. The delivery driver chuckled and decided to test it himself. To everyone’s surprise, as soon as he left his engine idling outside, the classic rock station abruptly switched to Bing Crosby singing ‘White Christmas.’ The whole town started talking about it, but nobody could figure out why only Casey’s parking lot had such magical powers. Even today, some say if you visit on a particularly snowy night, you might just hear a few bars of ‘Jingle Bells’ while filling up your tank.

4. One autumn afternoon, a delivery driver pulled into Casey's General Store for a much-needed break. As he stepped inside, he overheard an old timer whispering to a friend: 'You won’t believe what happened here last week—some guy bought a gallon of milk, then came back five minutes later to buy another one!' The delivery driver grinned and shook his head, thinking it was just another quirky thing about small-town life. Later that evening, as he drove home through the quiet streets, he saw an elderly gentleman standing outside Casey's with two empty jugs. The man waved cheerfully, muttering something about needing ‘just one more’.