Casey's

About this location

A few stories people tell about this place

1. One morning, a delivery driver pulled up to Casey's and noticed something strange: every time he parked near the pump, his car radio started playing the same old country song. 'What in the world?' he muttered, turning it off only to hear it start again as soon as he restarted the engine. Finally, a local DJ overheard the story and decided to have some fun. He played that same country tune every time someone filled up at Casey's—just for kicks. Now, whenever anyone mentions Casey's, they laugh and say, ‘Better bring your own playlist!’

2. A local woman stopped by Casey's one afternoon and asked the attendant, ‘Why does everyone here seem so darn cheerful?’ The clerk replied with a smile, ‘Oh, they’re not always like this—just when it’s almost closing time.’ Soon after, an older gentleman walked in and said, 'I heard you guys are always happy near closing.' The attendant winked and answered, 'Yep, just trying to make our last customers' day brighter!'

3. A regular customer entered Casey's one evening and exclaimed, 'I just saw the strangest thing!' The attendant raised an eyebrow, curious. ‘While I was filling up,’ he continued, ‘this delivery driver walks in wearing a gorilla suit! He’s dancing around, honking like a horn, and singing something about “octopus’s garden.” Everyone inside started laughing so hard they almost forgot to pay.’ The attendant shook his head with a smile, thinking it must be another typical Casey’s adventure.

4. A curious cat frequently visited Casey's late at night, always sitting in exactly the same spot by the window. One night, a delivery driver arrived with an extra-large pizza and asked curiously, ‘Who orders this much pie?’ The cat looked up from its usual perch, blinked twice, then walked over to the door as if signaling someone inside. The employee shrugged and said, “Just another night at Casey's.”