Sully's Olive

About this location

A few stories people tell about this place

1. At Sully’s Olive, a regular noticed something peculiar one morning. As he filled up his truck, he heard an unusual announcement over the loudspeaker: ‘Attention, everyone—our newest employee is so good at counting olives, she can do it blindfolded.’ Soon enough, a delivery driver walked in and asked for an olive count as well. The manager shook their head with a smile, but the driver insisted. To everyone’s surprise, she counted every single olive flawlessly—and then some extra ones no one could see! Turns out, she was just really good at making things up on the spot.

2. At Sully’s Olive, an unusual item appeared on the parking lot one foggy afternoon. A delivery driver had mistakenly left behind a crate marked ‘organic olives’—but inside were not olives, but dozens of tiny handwritten notes addressed to local residents. The notes turned out to be love letters from a mysterious neighbor confessing undying affection for various locals. The whole town was amused and touched, especially when Sully posted them on social media with hashtags like #Oliverations and #LoveNotesFromNowhere. It became a quirky tradition until someone finally tracked down the anonymous suitor—a shy librarian who’d been pining away for months.

3. At Sully’s Olive, a little girl pointed excitedly at the window one day. Her mother glanced up and saw nothing but the usual bottles of oil. ‘What did you see?’ asked her mom curiously. The girl replied, ‘A unicorn!’ The mother shook her head with a smile, thinking maybe her daughter had finally outgrown her imaginary friends. But just then, an older gentleman walked in, looked at the same spot, and exclaimed, 'I thought I saw a rainbow!' Turning to each other, they laughed, realizing that sometimes, even adults need a little magic.

4. At Sully’s Olive, a delivery driver swore he saw a ghostly figure carrying baskets of olives late one night. The delivery driver told everyone at the station, and soon word spread around town. One evening, a neighbor popped into Sully’s and asked if they could get some extra olives for their secret recipe. The cashier quipped, ‘We’ll see what olives the ghost brings tonight!’ Turned out, it was just an old crate left behind—comical but good-natured fun.